Friday 29 August 2014

Video Game Blog - Super Smash Sexism?


For years Nintendo has been renowned for being a family friendly gaming company that plays it safe with its happy go lucky cast. Characters such as Mario, Link and Donkey Kong, appeal to young demographics whilst also retaining enough charm for the older generation of gamers… Which is why this blog entry may come as a bit of a shock.

Recently, Nintendo has come under criticism for the character design of Zero Suit Samus in both Super Smash Brothers for Wii U and 3DS. The character debuted in the Smash Brothers series back on the Wii and has seen some changes made to her design since then.

Zero Suit Samus. Killer of aliens, wearer of stilettos.

Yes, this is a Nintendo Game
Undeniably, next to the rest of the Nintendo universe this incarnation of Samus stands out for obvious reasons. With her skin tight suit, exaggerated physique and bleach blonde hair, Zero Suit Samus (who shall now be referred to as ZSS) is a highly sexualised character that stands out immensely whilst stood next to a stodgy Italian plumber. Recent criticisms of the character design have stemmed from the fact that the character now wears high heels (rocket powered high heels to be precise). Despite the criticisms of the design, Nintendo didn't hold back from showing ZSS’s alternate costume on a Nintendo Direct, which really doesn't stray away at all from the vibe ZSS was giving off.

To me this reveal feels like a wii bit of a blunder (puns, the lowest form of wit), the costume is from an old Metroid game from the Game Boy Advance (Metroid: Zero Mission) which Nintendo is just trying to pay homage to… But I think when you step into the realm of somewhat realistic looking graphics you need to be very careful to not present your characters like a piece of meat. I don’t think that Nintendo needs to hide away ZSS, hell pretty much the entire cool factor of Samus’ character comes from the fact that she is a female. But some realistic body proportions and some plausible foot wear might make a bit more sense.

The original Metroid itself, released in 1986 drew various elements from Ridley Scott’s 1979 hit science fiction horror Alien, notably the female protagonist. Playing as a girl in a super powered mech suit was a pretty innovative idea for the time, but I don’t think anyone took Samus’ sexualisation as seriously when she was just a bunch of 2D pixels. (Check out her death animation from Super Metroid on the attached link). I can see why some may be offended, but looking at some of Nintendo's recent design choices and games on the horizon it does beg the question of whether this is a trend for the company? Is Nintendo trying to change their image? Rounding off this blog with a few final screenshots and comments.

Please comment below if you have any thoughts on the subject, thought this would be an interesting blog to start off with.

Thanks for reading.
Actual promotional image for Mario Kart 8. All of the female characters (excluding the one that is you know... A MUSHROOM) abandon their dresses for leather biking suits. Needing a change of clothes in a world where apes and dinosaurs can drive go kart's is a bit of a reach. Specially as Mario rides a bike quite easily in plumbing overalls.

Bayonetta was one of the most sexually provocative games and characters all time on the Playstation 3 and Xbox 360. Bayonetta 2 launches EXCLUSIVELY on the Wii U.

This is a screenshot from a ZELDA GAME. To be precise Hyrule Warriors isn't a game made by Nintendo, it's being created by KOEI for Nintendo, but still. All I see is tits.

8 comments:

  1. That Bayonetta shot is ridiculous, is that a legit promo shot?!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't think so, quality is too poor. It's likely an in game cutscene shot with a logo slapped over it.

      Delete
  2. The Zero suit was originally created to introduce stealth gameplay mechanics to Metroid: Zero Mission on GBA by taking Samus out of her normal protective armoured power suit and leaving her vulnerable. It was then updated to a more detailed form for Smash Bros Brawl to take advantage of the Wii's greater graphical power. It was not designed to be sexually appealing but as a obvious design choice to fit the gameplay. What do people expect Samus to be wearing underneath her suit? She would have to have a slim/athletic physique and wear form fitting clothing to fit in that thing. This is one character from a roster of around 40 and none of the other female characters have been 'sexed up'. Part of the appeal of the Smash Bros games is that they bring together a huge number of differently styled characters that create a fun juxtaposition. I honestly don't see any of this as sexist. As a counter point the newly announced character Shulk from Xenoblade has an alternate costume of him wearing nothing but swimming trunks. I doubt there will be similar outcry about this as he is male. Perhaps that is the real sexism.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey! Thank you for checking out the blog. Appreciated. I'll be updating frequently with Nintendo related stuff so I hope you get a chance to check us out again.

      You bring up a variety of good points, but saying ZSS's design isn't moulded around sex appeal at all? Her entire character design oozes it. I personally don't think the character is sexist, BUT even by looking at the difference in character models from the Wii to Wii U her body has been made a bit well, breastier. That's what I think some of the rage is partly attributed to.

      As far as what to expect under Samus' suit, I certainly wouldn't expect heels...

      Delete
  3. Hi Mark! I am not a video game player but I did enjoy your article.It's actually interesting to hear a man bringing up the issue of sexism in video game and not only playing blindly with her hot barbie-like character. Just thought I will bring a little touch of feminism on what has been said and female representation in video games in general. Two points:

    1- I think there is definitly something about 'fantasy' and being able to control the female body for a male player. I do not think the girls represented in video game are being put in sexy outfits for 'convenience' but it is a deliberate choice to sell the product to male consummers.After all, if you are not able to get girls like Scarlett Johansson in real life why not make it happen when playing video game? The bonus is that you even get to control the girl! Not patriarchist at all...

    2- From a female audience perspective, it looks very third wave/post feminist to me. I mean, I'm not an expert but not only guys play video games, right? So when creating those over sexy representation the company might think that the female player want to identify with a hot/sexy character. It sort of spread the idea that if you want to be a powerful woman, you better not be ugly but hot (still sounds pretty sexist to me).

    ReplyDelete
  4. I am not blind to the fact that sexist or sexual imagery exists in the video game industry, as it does in any other, in fact there are clearly games that are blatant about it (senran kagura) but I feel this game/ character and Nintendo are unfairly singled out in this case. Sexist imagery in video games is not solely the preserve of female characters either. Whilst there may be plenty of examples of scantily clad women there are just as many depictions of muscle bound, 'pretty boy' male characters that create just as many expectations of beauty for boys/men. Unless there is a specific reason, be it for a particular type of character, story or theme, no one ever designs anything to be ugly. It is natural when creating something to make it beautiful and therefore many of these characters are designed with a fair amount of attractiveness. Is there an optimum level of attractiveness or body image that is acceptable? It's a very subjective view in any case.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Yeah, before I'd even seen P Edwards comment Chloe I was going to post a picture of a typical 'male' video game character.

    http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/13/130805/3077117-kratos-bd2.jpg

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi, I find reading this article a joy. It is extremely helpful and interesting and very much looking forward to reading more of your work.. koktale

    ReplyDelete